Arch Manning gave Texas fans a night that was difficult to sum up with a single stat line. He threw three interceptions and struggled for much of Saturday’s game against LSU. Then, with the Longhorns’ season hanging in the balance, he led a 58-yard drive that ended with a four-yard touchdown pass to Raleek Brown with three seconds left.
That resilience prompted a bold comparison from Paul Finebaum. Appearing on ESPN’s First Take on Monday, the college football analyst called Manning “the gutsiest quarterback I have seen since Tim Tebow,” adding that he had never seen anyone put a team on his back after making as many mistakes. The remark was shared by Awful Announcing.
Manning’s mistakes made the finish matter more
The comparison was about toughness and response, not a claim that Manning has matched Tebow’s accomplishments. Manning finished 19-of-35 for 174 yards, one touchdown and three interceptions in Texas’ 22-21 victory. His last throw, however, gave the Longhorns their first win at LSU’s Tiger Stadium since 1952.
“He’s the gutsiest quarterback I have seen since Tim Tebow, I have never seen anybody put a team on his back after screwing up as much as he has” – Paul Finebaum on Arch Manning https://t.co/z0TqnDnRsg
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) November 16, 2026
Manning completed six of eight passes for 51 yards on the final drive and added 10 rushing yards, according to Texas. The drive capped an 11-point second-half comeback and turned a night full of frustration into a defining moment for the Longhorns.
Finebaum also acknowledged that his earlier praise of Manning had gone too far. Before Manning had played a college game, Finebaum called him the best quarterback since Tebow. This time, he narrowed the comparison to Manning’s grit after a difficult performance.
MORE: Curt Cignetti defends Lincoln Riley after Indiana’s win leaves USC facing more questions
Texas needed more than one heroic drive
Manning’s late work was the headline, but the comeback was a team effort. Texas kicker Gianni Spetic made field goals of 41 and 50 yards in the second half, while the Longhorns’ defense kept LSU scoreless in the fourth quarter and forced four straight punts.
That context makes Finebaum’s comment both striking and debatable. Manning did not play a clean game, and Texas needed its defense and special teams to keep the deficit within reach. But the quarterback had to put the interceptions behind him and make the final drive count. Against LSU, he did.


