The Knicks danced in confetti in June, relishing their first title in a generation off the backs of Jalen Brunson, Karl-Anthony Towns, Mike Brown and more.
Four months on, a lot of the goodwill that seemed to fall at the feet of New York owner James Dolan for his willingness to bankroll that title-winning unit appears to have vanished.
The 71-year-old has drawn the ire of many basketball enthusiasts in recent decades. A Trump acolyte who was forced to settle a dispute with a former Knicks executive who alleged that he fired her after filing a sexual harassment report against former New York president Isiah Thomas, Dolan is hardly a popular figure in sports.
He didn’t do himself any favors with the his latest trick, one that saw him fool masses of Madison Square Garden employees hoping to get a chance to deck their fingers in gold after New York’s championship triumph.
Here’s what you need to know about the Knicks phishing scandal that took social media by storm.
MORE: Former ESPN personality, current Trump staffer throws beer on NBA fan
Knicks championship ring cybersecurity test
Dolan’s passion for surveillance is well-documented at this point. Madison Square Garden has been less a sporting venue that a panopticon for Dolan, wrote Wired’s Noah Shachtman and Robert Silverman in April 2026. The pairing, alongside investigative journalist Pablo Torre, helped reveal the extent of Dolan’s obsession with cybersecurity, detailing how, among other things, Dolan’s security staff harassed and “obsessively tracked” a trans woman over a two-year period.
Perhaps it’s unsurprising, then, to see Dolan and Co. return to the well once more, this time directing their efforts towards their own employees.
Dolan’s company picked quite the ruse as a trojan horse to pursue its obsession with biometrics. The Athletic’s Joe Vardon detailed the scope of Dolan’s fixation in an article that came out Thursday. Vardon reported that the Knicks governor reportedly sent an email to employees vowing to offer them the choice of a potential championship ring.
MORE: Where Ty Jerome ranks for NBA MVP odds will leave basketball fans shocked
“Congratulations, your Employee Championship Ring is here,” the email read, per The Athletic.
“[Employee name], this one is on the house. MSG is issuing a complimentary employee championship ring. The same jeweler, the same craftsmanship, personalized with your name. No cost to you.
“There are two designs to choose from: Championship Gold and Garden Classic. Reserve the one you want below.”
The email was a scam, however. The message was actually a phishing test, used to see if Madison Square Garden employees would click on the link featured at the bottom of the page. If they did, they were greeted not with jewelry, but with a mandatory cybersecurity class, per Vardon.
MORE: Charles Oakley vs. James Dolan beef, explained
Did Knicks employees actually get championship rings?
Many longtime employees at Madison Square Garden employees are not expected to receive a championship ring for their troubles, per Vardon. Dolan has shown an unwillingness to part ways with his hordes of money over the years; ESPN’s Shams Charania reported that New York’s latest contract extension offer to star big Karl-Anthony Towns is worth more than $75 million less than he’s eligible for.
Dolan’s unwillingness to give just rewards to players who have served his franchise dutifully appears to be a window into his frugality. Predictably, that stinginess is also reserved for mere mortals, including those that make up the masses of the Madison Square Garden workforce.
Others subjected to the whims of the Dolan’s parsimony appear to include select New York assistants, who have not yet received their signets.
MORE: Donald Trump-James Dolan friendship, explained
Online reaction to Knicks championship ring cybersecurity test
Observers far and wide condemned Dolan and Co.’s actions on social media. Here are some of the more notable reactions to Dolan’s controversial actions:
This is kind of breaking my heart what a cruel thing to do in the face of joy
— amanda (@jailedamanda) October 23, 2026
This is absolutely horrible and complete crap by the Knicks. Shame on them for not only holding the assistant coaches rings during the ceremony, but doing this with their employees. What a complete joke.
— Brett Siegel (@BrettSiegelNBA) October 23, 2026
You have to be a truly terrible person to do this https://t.co/1v9Znnd3WG
— Jeremy Schneider (@J_Schneider) October 23, 2026
Back in the day, we did a phishing test with a client who had recently removed free soda as an employee benefit. One of the things that our phishing email asked employees to log in and fill a survey about was if they would like to see free sodas returned to the workplace. The employees were so excited by the phishing email that they forwarded it around to each other to ensure that everybody got a copy and could log in and fill it out. Needless to say, the client was furious, and we all learned a very valuable lesson about running the content of the phishing emails by the client and their corporate communications team before sending it to their employees.
— Joe Barrett (@BarrettJ) October 23, 2026
Nobody is saying “the Knicks should never do phishing tests.” We’re saying “teasing employees with information about rings they earned but may not receive is unnecessarily cruel.” Because it is. Have a shred of respect for the people who work for you.
— Sam Quinn (@SamQuinnCBS) October 23, 2026
Do you know how pissed I would be…. my god.
— Devin Newsom (@DevinNewsom) October 23, 2026
James Dolan won the title and called a crisis PR firm for an emergency strategy meeting to come up with new ways to demonstrate that he is still Evil
— Rodger Sherman (@rodger) October 23, 2026
Knicks employees: “We getting championship rings?” James Dolan: https://t.co/SeiAo1r9gb
— Josiah Johnson (@KingJosiah54) October 23, 2026


